Part 1 of this 2-part HR Compliance Budgeting Guide dives into the essential compliance items you need to account for in the new year. Featuring a practical 5-step framework, you can plan, prioritize, and secure your 2027 budget by outlining key requirements, hidden considerations, and strategic steps for success.
What to Plan For, What to Prioritize, and How to Get It Right
Building an HR budget involves much more than planning for salaries, benefits, and recruiting. HR compliance requirements can create significant expenses throughout the year as well, from technology and reporting to audits, training, expert guidance, and remediation. Not to mention any fines or penalties that come from non-compliance.
This guide is for HR professionals who play a role in planning, managing, or approving HR compliance budgets. Whether you’re building the HR budget from scratch or reviewing an existing plan, use this guide to identify the compliance expenses, resources, and potential risks you should consider for 2027.
The guide begins with a framework for assessing your current compliance obligations, identifying gaps, and aligning compliance spending with your organization's goals. It then walks through key areas of HR compliance and related budget expenses. You'll also find guidance on evaluating completing the tasks in-house versus outsourcing them to a compliance management partner, questions to ask potential partners, and practical ways to use AI when building and refining your budget.
Note: This guide is intended as a budgeting resource and is not a comprehensive list of every federal, state, or local employment requirement that may apply to your organization.
Building Your HR Compliance Budget Framework
Follow these five key steps when building your HR compliance budget and move to a proactive strategy.
Step 1: Audit Your Current Compliance Obligations
Start by identifying which requirements apply to your organization. Ask:
- Are we a federal contractor or subcontractor?
- What employee-count thresholds apply to us?
- In which states do our employees work and where do we advertise jobs?
- What local requirements apply?
- What industry-specific requirements apply?
- Do we have remote or hybrid employees?
- What reports and filings are required?
- What compliance activities recur annually?
- Which activities require specialized technology or outside expertise?
Step 2: Identify Compliance Gaps
Your current year experience can help identify where your future budget needs additional resources. Review:
- Audit findings and subsequent action items
- Missed or delayed filings
- Outdated policies or processes
- Manual processes
- Data quality issues
- Compliance related incidents
- New federal, state, or local requirements
- Areas where internal HR capacity was insufficient
- Projects that were deferred because of budget constraints
- Areas where actual spending exceeded the budget
Step 3: Map Budget Categories to Deadlines and Reporting Cycles
Compliance expenses are easier to manage when they are connected to the time of year they will occur. Make sure you identify:
- Annual reporting deadlines
- Audit cycles
- Training requirements
- Poster and notice update cycles
- Compensation and pay-equity review cycles
- State reporting deadlines
- Use an HR compliance calendar to organize requirements throughout the year
Step 4: Determine Budget Flexibility and Contingency
Not every compliance expense can be predicted. Separate your budget into three categories of expenses.
| Recurring Expenses | One-Time Expenses | Contingency Expenses |
|---|---|---|
|
|
|
Step 5: Align Your Compliance Budget with HR and Business Strategy
Your compliance budget should reflect where your organization is headed and not just where it is today. Consider the following that could impact your requirements:
- Planned hiring
- Workforce growth
- Expansion into new states
- Remote-work changes
- Mergers or acquisitions
- New federal contracts
- Changes to HR technology
- New compensation strategies
- Changes to DEI or employment programs
Key Compliance Requirements to Anchor Your 2027 Budget
- Form I-9 compliance
- Federal contractor obligations
- Federal reporting
- Merit-based Employment
- State-level requirements
- Compensation strategy
- Labor law posters
Form I-9 Compliance
Form I-9 compliance doesn't end once a form is completed. Employers need processes for completing, verifying, storing, retaining, and auditing I-9 records. Changes in workforce size, remote or hybrid work options, federal contractor status, and government enforcement can also affect the resources required to manage the process.
| What to Budget For | Additional Considerations |
|---|---|
|
|
Ask Yourself: Are we budgeting for ongoing I-9 management and audit preparation or only for the hiring process itself?
Federal Contractor Requirements
Federal contractors may have additional requirements and obligations that private employers do not have. Meeting these requirements can necessitate accurate workforce data, specialized analysis, reporting expertise, and ongoing compliance monitoring.
| What to Budget For | Additional Considerations |
|---|---|
|
|
Ask Yourself: Do we have the resources and expertise to meet our federal contractor obligations before deadlines arrive? HR compliance as a service (HR CaaS) partners, such as OutSolve, can help you in all these areas.
Merit-Based Employment
Organizations should have processes for evaluating employment practices that help identify potential disparities. Employers subject to federal contractor requirements, demonstrating that employment decisions are merit-based can be particularly important. It is required for recent executive orders and can result in False Claims Act penalties if not followed.
| What to Budget For | Additional Considerations |
|---|---|
|
|
Ask Yourself: Can we demonstrate that our employment practices are merit-based and non-discriminatory and feel confident about certifying?
Labor Law Posters
Labor law posting requirements can vary by federal, state, and local requirements. Posters may also change throughout the year, making ongoing monitoring important for employers with multiple locations or remote employees.
| What to Budget For | Additional Considerations |
|---|---|
|
|
Ask Yourself: Would a one-time poster purchase provide enough coverage, or would an automatic subscription service better protect the organization throughout the year? OutSolve offers a comprehensive labor law poster service.
Pay Equity, Benchmarking & Pay Transparency
Compensation planning increasingly involves more than setting competitive salaries. Employers may need to evaluate pay equity, benchmark compensation annually, comply with pay transparency requirements, and prepare state pay data reports.
| What to Budget For | State & Local Considerations |
|---|---|
|
|
Don't Forget Remediation: A pay-equity analysis can identify issues that require additional investment. Consider budgeting for:
- Salary adjustments
- Market adjustments
- Compensation structure changes
- Job architecture
- Additional analysis or legal review
Ask Yourself: If a pay equity audit identifies disparities, have we budgeted for what comes next?
Additional Compliance Budget Considerations
The following areas may also have compliance expenses depending on your organization's size, industry, workforce, and locations.
State and Local Reporting
State and local requirements can create significant complexity for multi-state employers. HR should consider not only the jurisdictions where employees work today, but also locations the organization expects to enter into in the future.
| What to Budget For | Additional Considerations |
|---|---|
|
|
Ask Yourself: Are we budgeting for every jurisdiction where our employees work, and not just where our headquarters is located?
Workplace Safety & OSHA Reporting
Workplace safety compliance can involve reporting, recordkeeping, training, workplace assessments, and physical safety investments.
| What to Budget For | Key Timing |
|---|---|
|
|
Ask Yourself: Have we budgeted for both OSHA reporting requirements and the investments needed to maintain a safe workplace?
Benefits Management & ACA Reporting
Benefits administration can create its own compliance, reporting, and communication costs.
| What to Budget For | Ask Yourself |
|---|---|
|
Are benefits compliance costs included in the HR budget or “hidden” elsewhere in the organization? |
Employee Development & Engagement
Employee development and engagement programs may include both compliance-related requirements and broader workforce investments.
| What to Budget For | Ask Yourself |
|---|---|
|
Have we accounted for both required compliance training and the technology and employee time needed to administer it? |
Leave Management
Leave administration can require significant administrative resources, particularly for employers operating across multiple states with different leave requirements.
| What to Budget For | Considerations |
|---|---|
|
|
Ask Yourself: Would leave administration be more cost effective and reliable with dedicated technology or outside support?
AI & Automated Employment Management Tools
AI and automated tools are increasingly used in recruiting, hiring, promotions, performance management, and other employment decisions. HR should consider whether these tools create additional compliance requirements, monitoring, documentation, or vendor-management needs.
| What to Budget For | Ask Yourself |
|---|---|
|
Are we using, or planning to use, AI tools that could create new compliance responsibilities? |
Background Screening Compliance
Background screening can involve federal, state, and local requirements, as well as processes for managing adverse actions and overseeing screening vendors.
| What to Budget For | Ask Yourself |
|---|---|
|
Are our background screening practices compliant across every jurisdiction where we hire? |
Ready to Build Your 2027 HR Compliance Budget?
Schedule a free consultation with an OutSolve compliance specialist to discuss your organization's compliance priorities, potential gaps and 2027 budget needs. Stay tuned for Part 2 that helps you evaluate whether you can complete HR compliance tasks in-house or if they need to be outsourced, key questions to ask compliance vendors, and how to use AI to refine your compliance budget.
Comments